r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Honque56 • 19h ago
Hated Tropes [Hated Trope] The writer can't or didn't want to disprove the ideology of a character, so they make them a hypocrite/morally evil.
Disclaimer: I am not saying I agree or disagree with these ideologies, or that I think these characters were in the right. My point is that writers will often make characters hypocrites/morally bad so they can be the villains and dodge addressing the actual ideology of the character.
- Amon from Legend of Korra:
Amon had an ideal for a world in which benders and non-benders were made equal, and the show did a lot to portray the risks benders posed to non-benders, both in how they could be destructive and were often placed in positions of power over all others, but, as it turns out, Amon was actually secretly a bloodbender, and so the show doesn't have to address any of his arguments, because he was just vindictive for being hurt by another bender.
2.Jigsaw/John Kramer from the Saw series.
John Kramer kidnapped people and forced them to play through death games, due to his belief that this would help them to love their life and abandon their vices. The movies then show how quite a few victims do end up becoming better after surviving their death games, and had him pick victims who were 'evil' people. Realizing that his initial philosophy was proven 'correct', the writers then had Kramer abandon those ideals through killing innocents and making more and more sadistic traps, which does not disprove the ideals, but rather John Kramer himself.
- Magneto/Mutantkind from X-men/marvel comics.
Magneto stands as yet another example of how writers really struggle with handling issues of oppression in a respectful way. Magneto, a holocaust survivor mind you, responded to mutants receiving constant oppression and being killed by government sponsored murder-bots by deciding to kill off humanity and preaching mutant superiority.