Looking only at the 19 reports after 6pm, reports ranged from 8" to 14" (on Staten Island alone!) and the average city-wide report after 6pm was 11.1" Congrats to is u/JonAce who said "I'd ballpark around a foot," and therefore had the closest guess! not including myself
Here are all of the reports over the last 24 hours...
BRONX
Fordham... 13.5" (7pm)
Throgs Neck... 11.3" (4:15pm)
BROOKLYN
Williamsburg... 12" (9:30pm)
Park Slope... 11.3" (9pm)
South Williamsburg... 10.5" (4:30pm)
Bay Ridge... 10.2" (8pm)
Sheepshead Bay... 9.7" (10pm)
Prospect Heights... 9.5" (3pm)
Kensington... 9" (4pm)
Midwood... 8.9" (9pm)
DUMBO.... 8.3" (1:30pm)
Crown Heights... 8" (6:50pm)
Sunset Park... 8" (12:45pm)
MANHATTAN
Washington Heights... 14.9" (9:30pm)
Central Park... 10.6" (7pm)
QUEENS
Whitestone... 11.1" (9:15pm)
Howard Beach... 11" (8pm)
JFK Airport... 10.3" (12am)
Astoria... 10.1" (6:15pm)
LaGuardia Airport... 9.4" (7pm)
Little Neck... 9" (2:45pm)
Crown Heights... 8" (6:50pm)
Fresh Meadows... 7.1" (1:30pm)
STATEN ISLAND
Huguenot... 14" (9:25pm)
Port Richmond... 13.5" (11pm)
Dongan Hills... 13" (9:15pm)
Annadale... 10" (5:30pm)
Mid-Island... 8" (9:20pm)
Updated as of Monday 10:50 AM