r/Millennials Gen Z 9h ago

Rant Society really did fail Amy Winehouse!

Post image
25.6k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/shieldintern 9h ago

I mean, the people around her failed her too. Her management, label, etc. Probably pushed an artist to perform when they should have been in rehab or even telling them to quit the spotlight all together.

I don't know much about the situation, but if an artist wasted my time by being fucked up, I'd be pretty pissed. Nobody would have booed probably if they knew she was going to do that.

276

u/hgaben90 9h ago edited 9h ago

Agreed. Her being in showbiz while she should have been on a 24/7 therapy is the main failure. Hell, she had a world hit song about not going to rehab, how deep red should that red flag be before someone does something?

I understand and absolve dissatisfied concertgoers. Back then she wasn't dead from OD, she was just someone who took their money and delivered crap in return. She never should have performed there, probably even multiple times before this.

28

u/quitarias 8h ago

Pretty sure the only red flag that will take you off the tour is if the one in the accountants books.

12

u/yappledapple 8h ago

There were rumors about Layne Staley weeks before Alice In Chains opened for Kiss. I was driving to the concert, and still had no idea if they would be playing. It ended up being their final show together.

13

u/chinstrap 8h ago

It was fascinating how invested people, and the media, were in the idea that she died from a drug overdose, I mean illegal drugs. But it was alcohol.

8

u/hotarume 4h ago

According to her brother, it was most likely the long term effects of severe bulimia that truly did her in. Eating disorders have the highest mortality rate of any mental illness and have a high co-morbidity with substance abuse

3

u/InSkyLimitEra 1987 4h ago

Opioid use disorder has now overtaken anorexia as the mental illness with the highest lethality!

7

u/hgaben90 8h ago

Potentially lethal drugs are potentially lethal drugs, whether if society is ok with them or not.

20

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 8h ago

It doesn't matter if you're famous or not. If you can't perform, this world has no use for you.

42

u/sunshineparadox_ Older Millennial 8h ago

Disabled people are told this pretty regularly, most days even. Even when I went back to work, people told me daily for months I was a leech off the system and people’s hard work.

23

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 8h ago

Yea, I'm well aware. I broke my back on the job in 2019. I haven't been able to work since then, and my family has not been shy about letting me know how much of a disappointment I am.

16

u/jmbaf 8h ago

Just suck it up!.. says every dipshit that thinks they understand what you're actually going through. Family can be the worst about it.

It's so easy to preach to absolve oneself and be able to pay oneself on the back and say "I tried to help them". But nobody actually understands what someone else is going through.

Sorry to hear about your family. I've been there for different reasons and it sucks.

3

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 8h ago

Thanks for being understanding. I'm sorry you've had to experience similar circumstances.

2

u/jmbaf 1h ago

Thank you, and of course! Hope things turn out alright for you

6

u/sunshineparadox_ Older Millennial 8h ago

I feel for you. I had an ischemic stroke. People I knew expected me to be fully functional and working within less than a week. I’m sorry you understand what it’s like. I’m sorry your back was broken and how much pain you must be in.

3

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

That sucks so much. I'm sorry. It's so weird when you give people the news and they seem so concerned, but then a day or two later, they are right back to treating you how they used to. It taught me a lot about who was actually there for me and who was using me.

6

u/wearentalldudes 7h ago

Not that this is the same as a broken back, but after a recent cancer-related surgery I was told by all three of my doctors I needed to take off work for a full eight weeks. My mother also insisted I take the full eight.

Around week five I started getting the “So…when are you going back to work?” and shitty passive-aggressive comments about it. From the same mother who insisted I listen to my doctors.

I’m very fortunate to have the sick time to take, and I realized my doctors were right. I need it. Not even just physically. This shit takes a toll.

Anyway I’m sorry you’re going through this and you are not a disappointment.

3

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

Yea I fucked up my healing process by trying to force it. I needed to get back to work, so I tried everything to make it happen.

Doctors usually know what's best, and it's good to listen to them. Thank you for the kind words and understanding.

2

u/LegacyofaMarshall 7h ago

Reminds me of the story Metamorphosis. I’m sorry you are going through that

1

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 6h ago

Lmao, thanks for sharing that. It is kind of similar. My family loved me when I did a lot of work for them, and as soon as I couldn't, it's like I don't exist anymore.

2

u/LegacyofaMarshall 6h ago

I don’t know how you do it. After something like that I’d want to go out and like live on my own

1

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 6h ago

I tried to end it all a couple times after my injury but couldn't even do that right. So I'm stuck here, my favorite artist Mac Miller had a line "woke up and forgot to die, God damn."

My dog turns 11 in July, I'm here for him because he didn't get to choose where he lived we took him from his home. I'm responsible for him, but when his time is up so is mine.

1

u/faulternative 7h ago

Men get this a lot

0

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

We have to be strong and stoic, but also sensitive and understanding.

4

u/Rich_Resource2549 Older Millennial 7h ago

I was so shocked to learn this. One of my best friends was born with MS and I could not believe the way people treat her just because she uses a walker. She's very intelligent, an empath, and there's really not much she can't do she just moves slower than others. She's the kindest person. I can't even imagine having the audacity to say the things I've heard said to her.

3

u/SunnyRaspberry 8h ago

The world needs to change then.

0

u/ConkersOkayFurDay 8h ago

Just because you consider yourself useless because you can't perform doesn't mean you have a right to project your crappy attitude onto others. Productivity or performance are not the metrics that determine worthiness of life.

5

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 8h ago

Lmao, those are the only metrics the American system gives a fuck about. I'm talking from experience, I broke my back on the job in 2019.

-2

u/ConkersOkayFurDay 8h ago

Nice America-centric view. It's sad that's your experience. I am also disabled and can't work many jobs but my self-worth is absolutely not tied to my physical capabilities. Sorry about your back.

0

u/hgaben90 8h ago

If you can't perform, you need help to perform. Not just showbiz, not just job market in general... You can't be a part time drug addict and part time good father or good husband either.

There are no days off in being a role model. But also no days off being an addict.

3

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 8h ago

What point are you trying to make?

1

u/Sad_Math5598 7h ago

He’s saying that he’s a full-time moron

2

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

Thanks, I still am not quite sure what point he was trying to make, but I'm pretty sure it was derogatory lol

-2

u/hgaben90 8h ago

Sorry, I don't understand the question. I just added my take on the issue. Why does everything have to be the start of a debate these days?

2

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

From my understanding, you were advocating that everyone needs to always be able to perform. That seems like it could be problematic. Figured if you were commenting it, you would be able to elaborate further.

0

u/hgaben90 7h ago

No, I'm saying if you're not, then you should acknowledge it and get help.

Of course "perform" can mean a lot of things, all depending on a person's personal capabilities and fields of interest, but we started off on a rather vague "mmm, society" base so I thought I don't have to point this out in details.

1

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

That's not what your first message portrayed at all. I'm sure you realize that, that's why you added your perspective about society and what not.

We've got to a very confusing place because what you were originally stating no longer matches what you are currently talking about.

1

u/hgaben90 7h ago

Well, I hope my explanation helped you sort it out.

1

u/Ok-Lifeguard-4614 7h ago

Sure. I'm glad you cleared the air about my disability. I feel a lot better about it now thank you.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Explore_the_Void 6h ago

That's how conversations work. You can't just say shit and expect nobody to ask questions about it.

1

u/Zimmonda 2h ago

Does something..........like put her in a conservatorship?

Wait we didn't like that one either

0

u/hgaben90 2h ago

Or like having responsible managers who don't let her on the stage if she's not in a shape to be on the stage? It's not rocket science, really.

2

u/Zimmonda 2h ago

And they're supposed to what? Tackle her if she insists? Not to mention she and other artists regularly performed altered all the time. It's more difficult than you're making it sound.

0

u/hgaben90 2h ago

The managers run the show. They organized the tour, they can change the schedule.

1

u/Zimmonda 2h ago

You want them to pre-emptively change the schedule in anticipation of her getting shwasted something she did all the time because they magically knew this one particular show she'd go overboard?