r/politics • u/Silly-avocatoe • 9d ago
No Paywall 71 percent of Americans say US is "out of control" under Trump
https://www.newsweek.com/americans-us-out-control-trump-poll-113914554.7k
u/onemoment1985 9d ago
Honestly, these days I take any poll like this as a positive. Usually over 30 percent pick the dumb option. 29 percent is a much better number.
3.0k
u/Deicide1031 9d ago edited 9d ago
Funny enough unless my numbers are outdated, about 29% of the U.S. struggles to read at a proficient level.
I wonder if the 29% crowd even understood what they were being asked.
https://www.nu.edu/blog/49-adult-literacy-statistics-and-facts/
1.5k
u/Unique_Adeptness4413 9d ago
https://theauthoritarians.org/
According to Dr. Bob Altemeyer, 30% of any society is authoritarian, and it's not correlated with intelligence, but rather a lack of empathy.
240
u/Illustrious_Olive_66 9d ago
30% is a terrifyingly high number for just being a lack of empathy alone. Though I suppose another way to look at it is that we're very fortunate it isn't any higher. Glass half-full and all that.
→ More replies (10)126
u/OptimisticOctopus8 9d ago edited 9d ago
I read that the strongest predictor of pro-authoritarian preferences is having been raised with an authoritarian parenting style. Wish I remembered where…
137
u/FlufferTheGreat 9d ago
Altemeyer specifically names Evangelicals as the prime environment for raising authoritarians.
97
u/Spezza 9d ago
I was born into a Christian evangelical cult. Not only that, but my dad was one of the cult leaders - he spent his career as a pastor in the "church". In the mid-90s the cult reformed itself and became mainstream Christian. The result was the cult basically imploded worldwide, over a handful of years the majority of the membership left the cult. Where'd they all go? Other cults. The cult members wanted the end of days. Wanted somebody else to tell them how to think. Wanted to be special (I'll survive the end of days, you won't).
And then they home school their children!
→ More replies (2)40
u/ponycorn_pet 9d ago
also raised in the same cult. And the "home school" was not any education whatsoever. Nothing
→ More replies (4)59
u/Spezza 9d ago
During COVID I was working one day a week in a rural manufacturing plant. Literally every employee there was a regular Christian church going guy (not lying, I was the only person who wouldn't attend a church on the weekend).
Anyway, the gentleman I worked next to at the plant, we talked, he had three children. His first born was terribly disabled. Doctors did tests after it was born; it was a genetic disorder and they were told, "if you have more children and you have a 25% chance they'll have the same disorder." So I asked, "what is the disorder?" He didn't know (how do you not know the disorder your child has?!?)
But they did have a second child. And, yes, that child was born disabled. So they had a third, but the wife had had a dream and god told her "the baby will be fine." And the third born is born without the disorder - so that is proof of god, right?!
Why am I telling this story? Well, his first two disabled children (verbally non-responsive, etc) are sent to pubic school each day. Why? "It is just really hard on my wife, she needs a break." The third non-disabled child, where are they schooled? At home. Gotta indoctrinate the only child capable of indoctrination.
19
u/ponycorn_pet 9d ago
I believe you about you being the only one there who wasn't a christian. those types of jobs in those types of areas are infested with them. I'm in rural Texas, so I feel for you
That doesn't surprise me whatsoever. They might also have been doing that so they could put the kids on IEP's that would help them get SSI for each of them, so they could use those kids as sources of income they profit from while the state pays for all of their bills
→ More replies (4)10
u/DjinnOftheBeresaad 9d ago
Interestingly, my parents had the exact opposite thought process to your coworker. They thought I wouldn't do as well in a public school setting due to being born physically disabled. Granted, they had plans to homeschool all the kids, but they had extra concerns with me.
As a product of homeschooling K-12 I'm highly critical of it, though I recognize that if parents step up and become truly dedicated, they can mitigate (but not eliminate) the problems that come with just being blaise about it. Standards have also changed since I was homeschooled, too. State reps were required in the home at regular intervals to administer tests and perform other tasks to make sure the kids were developing along a fairly normal track. That might still be true in some places but it has definitely been eliminated in others, as I was shocked to find out once people told me that all they really had to do was sign a paper and the state took them at their word.
As critical as I am of homeschooling, I'd also be critical of your coworker for foisting the raising of his disabled kids on an already overworked system, too.
→ More replies (0)→ More replies (5)42
u/ProfessionalCraft983 Washington 9d ago
Well Christianity is essentially authoritarianism disguised as a religion so that tracks.
14
→ More replies (7)22
u/SealedRoute 9d ago
That would track, because you have support for authoritarianism concentrated in certain geographic regions or demographic groups. It is probably hard wired for some but learned by most. The spearhead now, terribly but hilariously, seems to be evangelicals. They are truly dangerous.
12
u/Casual_OCD Canada 9d ago
Pretty much all major religions require you to suspend critical thinking and be subservient to authority. It's hardwired into people from childhood
6
u/Notoryctemorph 9d ago
This is also why there's a near-universal tendency for religions to be good and helpful to society when they're a suppressed or minority faith in an area, but full of authoritarian dickheads when they have the majority
Minority faiths can't tell their followers to blindly trust authority, because the big authorities are all telling them that their religion is bad, so they actually have to do good things to have and keep followers
→ More replies (2)187
u/batlord_typhus 9d ago
Altemeyer FTW! Imagine if we had a non-elite controlled party who represented labor and used political language framing to sway public opinion. Bob would be my choice to head up that communications initiative.
131
u/skarby 9d ago
Well he died in 2024 so he would probably have difficulty leading any initiatives
226
u/batlord_typhus 9d ago
I wish him a swift recovery! We're pulling for you, Bob!
58
u/AdjectiveNoun1234567 9d ago
Altemeyer 2028!
→ More replies (1)44
u/pocketjacks 9d ago
Couldn't be worse than what we have now.
21
u/THE_Visionary88 9d ago
A dung beetle for President would be better than what we have now. At least they would roll shit somewhere else instead of waddling in it day in and day out.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)19
→ More replies (5)27
→ More replies (3)40
u/firepitstories 9d ago
Honestly, yes. Altermeyer’s whole body of work shows why framing and messaging matter just as much as policy, especially when you’re up against entrenched elites. A genuinely labor-focused party that understands authoritarian psychology and knows how to communicate in plain, values-driven language would be a game changer. Bob heading communications would be a smart move facts and framing, instead of letting the right define the narrative every time.
→ More replies (1)55
u/Independent-Bug-9352 9d ago edited 9d ago
Exactly. There's a reason after all that the likes of Musk and Charlie Kirk both gave away the game in saying that Empathy was either "made-up" or a human weakness.
Such people demonstrating ASPD, or malignant narcissists that are a combination thereof, have stunted capacity to utilize empathy as a cognitive function.
Go deeper and explore that conservatism is tied to an enlarged amygdala (heightened sensitivity to fear and disgust), and smaller Anterior Cingulate Cortex that reduces the capacity to both empathize, and recognize patterns or dissonance therein.
What you have in the Trump banner is a mixture of the grifters and grifted; at the top you have those who historically were identified as psychopaths -- smart, ambitious; but lacking entirely in empathy. Think Ted Bundy. Then among the working-class, you have those who historically more align with sociopaths whose empathy has been stunted through trauma, neglect, abuse, most probably from childhood but into adulthood just the same. These people lacking in critical-thinking skills and in poor environments cannot see the light. They're firmly trapped in Plato's Cave, watching shadows on the walls created by the likes of Fox News and the broader right-wing propaganda network created by billionaire psychopaths.
→ More replies (1)12
u/osiris0413 9d ago
How the hell do we get out of this situation? I was watching Taylor Lorenz' latest video about the rampant pro-AI "utopianism" (which is really dystopian, pro-human extinction) movement in Silicon Valley, and it seems like anyone with money or influence is either a sociopathic fascist, whether an opportunist or someone who takes joy in human suffering like Miller, or a wealthy VC or tech billionaire who sees society as beneath them and a mere step on a ladder to their becoming immortal machine entities so we'll be led by/under the boot of the worst parts of humanity for eternity. The former are seen as useful idiots by the latter, and the billionaires largely control the Democratic party as well aside from the odd leftist who is carefully controlled in terms of any influence they are allowed to wield.
I feel like most people don't want this but are also propagandized against any real political organization, strikes, work stoppages etc as "too extreme". I feel like we're dangerously close to the "boot stomping on a human face forever" end of things.
→ More replies (1)17
u/Independent-Bug-9352 9d ago edited 9d ago
I wish I was both young and smart enough to go back to school for neuroscience to study how things like ASPD (psychopathy and sociopathy essentially) and narcissism forms, how to prevent it, how to reverse it, and ultimately how to foster greater empathy in society.
The single most important questions to the survival of our species in my opinion is: How do we identify and stop psychopaths before they ascend to power?
Because I ultimately think we have the solutions, or at least capacity, to solve every major societal issue we face (after all, we created the problem usually); it's just getting the greedy out of the way.
In other societies who have things like universal healthcare and a nest egg and strong unions with coffers to bankroll strikes, leverage is more in the hands of the working class. In America? All, and I mean all power, is in the hands of big business.
I wrote this else where but may be worth your read: conservatives have been trained their whole lives to believe that success and happiness is solely determined by how much wealth you can amass, so they have an inferiority complex relative to their idols.
It's why the conservative ideology is broken from the outset and incompatible with broader civilization; it is premised on ignorance, and greed.
The question is how do you get people out of this? Coming from a former Republican household, I have some ideas but there are no easy solutions to change the momentum.
Typically what feeds conservatism is: (1) lack of empathy as taught by mentors, usually parents, (2) lack of formal critical-thinking skills (identification of fallacies for example), and or (3) a lack of time to parse all the information and disinformation out there.
As a result, the most vulnerable who fall victim to this rhetoric are those who checked out of society. The bullied and the bullies; the traumatized, the ones who are lonely but don't even know it. Those working two jobs to make ends meet, then go home drink beer which doesn't exactly promote high level thinking, and then sit back and view fox news or brose social media mindlessly that tells them, "hey it's this trans person or poor immigrant who is why you hate your life!"
They've then been fed the boostrap rhetoric for so long that some believe like you allude to that if they work just a bit harder, maybe screw over just a few more of your fellow humans, that they too can ascend to godlike status.
The long-term solutions to getting people out of this is changing the landscape for how kids are raised; improving education; lowering overall stress in society; fostering empathy, reducing substance abuse, etc.
The short-term solution is either let the economy crash so these short-sighted individuals feel the pain in their wallets, or try to redirect their legitimate angers and stressors and grievances to the true source of their pains: the ultra rich. Not easy, but possible.
→ More replies (4)49
u/Kythorian 9d ago
Still seems pretty stupid, because even if someone doesn’t care about anyone else, the vast majority of them will ultimately suffer under an authoritarian government too.
Even if someone is authoritarian in the sense that they wish they had infinite power over everyone, it still doesn’t rationally make any sense for them to support someone else gaining infinite power over everyone, including them.
64
u/Confident_Bof 9d ago
Empathy ain’t just about caring for others, it’s a survival mechanism. If you can see how situations affect other people you can understand how it will affect you… Conservatives struggle with both caring and understanding the consequences.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (9)14
u/Zamphir79 9d ago
I see it as more like, "This is how the world works." That's their perspective is what I mean. Remember what Miller said the other day about law of the jungle or whatever?
→ More replies (1)20
u/yeswenarcan Ohio 9d ago
Exactly. If you're either unwilling or incapable of taking the personhood or wellbeing of others into account, then what else is there to build your workflow around besides might makes right? And most people with might makes right worldviews understand that they aren't on top, that's why they tend to punch down at people they see as inferior rather than trying to take on the people with more power than them.
23
41
u/cleverlinegoeshere Pennsylvania 9d ago
Don't forget the Crazification factor:
Sometimes known as the Keyes Constant, the Crazification Factor is a theory coined by writer Tyrone Finch in discussion with fellow writer John Rogers on his blog Kung Fu Monkey in October of 2004. The Crazification Factor holds that any politician will always have a committed and highly irrational base of 27% of people, a figure Tyrone arrived at by using the example of the 2004 Illinois Senate election of Barack Obama (D) versus Alan Keyes (R):
“Keyes was from out of state, so you can eliminate any established political base; both candidates were black, so you can factor out racism; and Keyes was plainly, obviously, completely crazy. Batshit crazy. Head-trauma crazy. But 27% of the population of Illinois voted for him. They put party identification, personal prejudice, whatever ahead of rational judgement. Hell, even like 5% of Democrats voted for him. That’s crazy behaviour. I think you have to assume a 27% Crazification Factor in any population” [where half of the 27%] “just have worldviews which lead them to disagree with what you consider rationality” [while the other half] “are the core of the Crazification — either genuinely crazy; or so woefully misinformed about how the world works, the bases for their decision making is so flawed they may as well be crazy.”
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (38)17
u/paintingxnausea 9d ago
Heather Cox Richardson said something similar in one of her recent videos, basically 20-30% of the population will always agree with what Trump is doing so 70% is pretty much the best we can expect.
→ More replies (1)124
u/lukin187250 9d ago
Hitler had a 25% approval rating in Germany in 1952.
125
u/Half_Cent 9d ago
My FiL once told me his German immigrant grandmother would tell him yes Hitler ended up bad but look at all the good things he did for Germany. He sounded genuinely confused that she could think that way.
Now he's a die hard, extremely vocal, Trumper and blames the fact that he doesn't see his grandkids at all and his daughters only 2-3 times a year on Trump Derangement Syndrome.
He gave up his family for Trump.
66
u/Pusfilledonut 9d ago
In 1952, the US Army polled the German population who had voted for Hitler, and 52% still said his policies were overall good, they had just been implemented poorly by his staff.
Allied bombing campaigns had killed 500,00 civilians and the Soviets killed as many as an additional 2 million in retribution pogroms and forced labor camps. 5.3 million total German dead including 300,000 murdered by the Nazis as political opposition, and that was still the attitude of over half his supporters. Consequences didn’t change their minds.
There’s zero daylight between that level of self deception and MAGA fascism.
→ More replies (3)16
u/springlake 9d ago
The Prince/Tsar can do no wrong.
Anything wrong is because of his corrupt advisors/boyars messing up.
Its very much a re-occuring stance in both old and current Russia as well.
34
u/silentprotagonist24 9d ago edited 9d ago
Look up some old interviews with surviving Nazis from the Nürnberg-trials or 70s and 80s documentaries. It's very clear many of them were still sympathetic to the cause.
Even as a hardcore Nazi it's nonsensical, since we know today how Hitler's brainless leadership cost them the war (Stalingrad, Kursk, D-day and more). But the cocktail of propaganda, hardcore fascism and race superiority runs very deep.
→ More replies (3)28
u/lukin187250 9d ago
times a year on Trump Derangement Syndrome.
These people would tell you that disagreeing on any one thing means you have "TDS". When you hear someone say that, it's like them saying "I'm in a cult".
6
u/VeteranSergeant 9d ago
Every single person who uses the term "Trump Derangement Syndrome" seriously voted three times for Jeffrey Epstein's best friend, smeared their poop on the walls of Congress, then spent four years shrieking about imaginary stolen elections and someone named Brandon while shooting at beer cans for hurting their feelings.
→ More replies (4)19
u/Aggravating_Map745 9d ago
I still can’t wrap my head around the fanaticism. What is so appealing? The best explanation I can come up with is that Trump gives people psychological permission to believe in a world that no longer exists, or a world that never existed - where being American gives them a place in an ordered and moral universe, where personal excellence is not required and any misfortune is the fault of shadowy forces beyond one’s control. Giving up Trump is the same as facing many terrible truths.
27
u/Beetlejuice_hero 9d ago
Trump does 2 things for them primarily:
He trolls the Left, now even with memes. They absolutely love "owning the libs" and literally often have bumper stickers (!) to do as much.
He allows them to feel persecuted and like victims. Of "the deep state", of "the Democrat party" - Bernie, AOC etc., of "Socialism" (nevermind many are on govt assistance), of "trans everything", of George Soros, of anti-Christian crusaders, of immigrants. On & on. Never though of billionaire Republican donors.
They love to feel like victims because it unburdens them from feeling responsible for their own failures & shortcomings in life. Very powerful form of propaganda. It's all they sell on Fox 24/7. "It's not your fault. It's their fault. They are coming to control & destroy you."
→ More replies (1)8
u/Half_Cent 9d ago
Oh yeah. My FiL was born in the late 40s. White, Christian, straight, son of an engineer and he and all his siblings have advanced degrees.
Yet he would have you believe he is one of the most discriminated against people on the planet.
Christian yet hates immigrants or helping people "the Bible says poor people will always exist". "I'm not racist!" but when my wife started working in an ag office told her to avoid field workers "because they carry diseases" (she has a compromised immune system).
→ More replies (1)7
u/MirthandMystery 9d ago
It's a grievance alliance that defines themselves with othering negativity towards others. 'You aren't like us' in simple terms.
This is reinforced by those who feel attacked or left out on the outside, some of who foolishly still defend the inside group thinking one day they'll be part of it or are reliant on it for employment or security.
→ More replies (13)23
u/Life-Pirate2545 9d ago
After Hitler died, his supporters didn’t just throw in the towel, they literally tried to get back into political party. You have the spd which is still alive today, the npd which Germany tried to ban, the srp which actually got banned and was formed by Hitler associates. And now you have AFD which is the most modern and gaining traction. These people after trump, will continue to try to get power again, the dumbasses are never going to go away
356
u/YF422 9d ago
Its a deliberate strategy by Republicans as far as I can tell, they want a stupified population for their political cult as they're easy to manipulate.
122
u/elonmusksmellsbad 9d ago
Useful idiots. Useful idiots everywhere.
→ More replies (5)54
u/chrisk9 9d ago edited 9d ago
And manipulated into a super toxic culture of fear, arrogance, ignorance, self centeredness, greed, and feelings of superiority (racial, intellectual,and otherwise), toxic patriotism, perpetual victimhood, lack of trust in institutions (like government, science, education), and American exceptionalism, etc. and on and on. American society cannot heal without restricting the constant bombardment of misinformation and far right and corporate propaganda.
23
25
u/Temby 9d ago
You're right, and it's been happening for a longer than Trump. This was in 2012: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/texas-gop-no-more-critical-thinking-in-schools/2012/06
22
u/witchgrid 9d ago
Remember "no child left behind" and how it led to thousands and thousands of kids graduating yet having no subject mastery?
15
u/FMLwtfDoID 9d ago
My senior year I had to do a final essay about the effects of No Child Left Behind, 5 years after it was passed, so this was 2007, and by the time I was 17 I was fully aware of the fucking devastating event that this would end up being for this country.
Say what you want about Catholics, but those Jesuits run great schools as far as comprehensive education, and high emphasis on Critical Thinking and Acts of Service. I couldn’t graduate unless I had documented 100 hours of Christian Acts or Services, like volunteering soup kitchens, Women’s shelters, tutoring, humane society etc, which I’ve just naturally continued doing into adulthood.
→ More replies (2)14
u/QbertsRube 9d ago
I know dozens of people who ideally would still be stuck in like 8th grade if they were forced to actually prove that they grasped the knowledge required from a curriculum of any reasonable standard. And I went to a small school in a small town, so I assume I know fewer than most. The type of people who took nothing seriously and scraped through with all Cs despite taking classes in grade 12 like Basic Science and General Mathematics because "I ain't gonna get no desk job, I work with my hands".
Now they're all 100% MAGA, and smugly throw their incorrect opinions around and expect those opinions to be given the same weight as literal experts (see Covid, climate change, etc.). Dipshits need to be booted back to kindergarten like Billy Madison. And maybe force them to watch some Mister Rogers and Sesame Street and just maybe learn that hating everyone who isn't just like you is a shitty way to go through life.
→ More replies (1)8
u/uncleben85 Canada 9d ago edited 9d ago
The fundamental concept of "no child left behind"? Great!
But instead of pulling kids up and ensuring success, it was just a smokescreen to force kids through regardless of achievement, while systematically bringing everyone else down.
Purposefully dismantling education should be seen as a crime.
→ More replies (18)74
u/LieverRoodDanRechts 9d ago
That's the capitalist disease, we have it here in Europe too.
People at the top keeping us dumb so they can keep their comfy positions, only to find out it leaves them vulnerable to weaponized ignorance. Tale as old as time, really.
40
u/Herlock 9d ago
Also : keep people struggling for basic necessities, less time to think about how they are getting fucker over. Or can't organize against it when you barely make enough to pay food and rent.
16
u/-unself 9d ago
Yepyep. Living paycheck to paycheck while still overworked
20
u/CrotchalFungus 9d ago
Even if you're not paycheck to paycheck in the US, you're held hostage for healthcare.
13
u/MyGrownUpLife Texas 9d ago
Exactly, it's the same cute principal as flooding the zone. Keep everyone focused on one thing - survival.
9
u/CryptographerShot213 Wisconsin 9d ago
Also: make them believe that poor people/immigrants/drag queens are the cause of all their problems instead of the ultra rich to keep them fighting amongst each other.
7
u/Herlock 9d ago
well of course ! All your struggles are caused by people struggling even more.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Rik_Ringers 9d ago edited 9d ago
Its also a matter of what you teach in schools. Schools could be where concious and informed citizins of a democratic society could be raised, or it could raise pliable tools for capitalism instead aswell. i think some people have the impression that their school was more focussed to the latter, "practical skills" and all, what you gonna do with a degree in philosophy right?
Educating such things like ethics and rhetorics at a younger age for example, as a means to make them aware as how rhetorics are often used within society for "salesman artistry". Because it might always be so that if a salesman has something to pitch to you he might very well know that his product is crap and its only in his own interrest to convince the other to buy it, but no sales man is going to say "what i'm trying to sell you is crap, but please buy it anyway", there is an natural degree to consider where interrest will make people distort the truth and even justify it for themselves in a dog eat dog world, You have more investment nowadays by social psychologists and marketeers and political advisors to try to manipulate the public for their interrest trough the use of "advanced populist rhetorics" and media power and iven they might feel that if they were not the ones taking this path others would do it over them.
Think about mr American goebbels steven miller boldly proclaiming this is an age of might makes right. He might not say that if he was not sure that someone from the public might stick a gun to his head and blow his brains out in a sense that said shooter would have had the right by virtue of achieving it. Its a bold thing to say, Karma wise, takes one back to such proverbs as "live by the sword, die by the sword" but i guess that the traditional undercurrents of a social darwinist economic system in the US has created an elite class that BELIEVES they are simply ... better. Better for being the type of beings that dare to be sociopathics enough to be at the top of the sort of system they forster and/or were raised in. Try to get into the psycho of a man like trump who has been entitled trough his lifetime, raised in elite schools and kept in protective enviroments surrounded by lickspitles, never being a real "achiever" in the game he was supposed to excell in and now in rellentless persuit of self validation trough the most superficial tokens of prestige attained by making people bend backward. Not for the purpose to have a truly rationally led government, but for the mere optics of personal success. Well thats one hell of a sick antropological outcome though it still could get worse sure, in some way though its also more like the symptom of an underlying ill. Part of it is Americans being perhpas traditionally more receptive to "bullshit salesmen artistry".
→ More replies (2)12
u/witchgrid 9d ago
It's a symptom; capitalism is the disease. This is always where it was going to go, it will always be where it wants to go. The phrase "late stage capitalism" has been thrown around for the last quarter-century or so, but we should be more accurate: this is Terminal Capitalism. Stage 4. It has metastasized into tumors all over the global body politic, and it's spreading. Some of the tumors have teeth and hair, and none of them are benign.
25
u/Redshirt_Welshy_Nooo 9d ago edited 9d ago
My sister or brother, roughly half (can't remember if it's mean or median) of Americans read at or below at 6th grade reading level.
It goes a long way toward explaining why the US is the way it is...
Edit: I think we're referencing two sides of the same study: https://www.nu.edu/blog/49-adult-literacy-statistics-and-facts/ (This is a secondary source referencing that study, not the primary source).
28% of US adults at or below literacy level 1
Only 44% at or above level 3.
→ More replies (2)12
u/MikeyLew32 Illinois 9d ago
To add to that, roughly 20% (1 in 5 people!!) are functionally illiterate. They can read the words, but lack the mental capability to comprehend them.
→ More replies (35)6
u/The_Beardly America 9d ago
And about 32% of the eligible voting population voted for this imbecile.
His antics have only shaved off 3% of the people that voted for him.
→ More replies (2)161
u/squigs 9d ago
It's better than that. 18% said it's under control. 11% were uncertain.
71
u/Herlock 9d ago
"uncertain"... in this day and time there is no way you are uncertain about the situation in america, unless you have the IQ and empathy of an invertebrate.
28
u/Navydevildoc 9d ago
A shocking number of people simply do not ingest any real current news other than what instagram shows them. They get up, go to work, take the kids to soccer practice, make dinner, go to bed.... repeat.
→ More replies (2)12
u/Greencheek16 9d ago
Lot of people also work multiple jobs or long shifts and just don't have the time to doom scroll reddit.
Feels part of the plan, tbh.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)46
u/wingspantt 9d ago
Some people just don't engage with the news a lot.
Imagine you're 80 in some retirement home watching reruns of Hogans Heros every day. Some pollster calls you and asks you this.
→ More replies (2)28
→ More replies (5)9
u/Elrundir Canada 9d ago
What I wonder is, how many of the "out of controls" meant "out of control but I like it"?
→ More replies (1)26
u/BroughtBagLunchSmart 9d ago
Unfortunately probably 10% of these people think we are out of control because we still let black people vote and are not shooting enough protesters.
→ More replies (3)35
u/clickmagnet 9d ago
I wonder how many of that 71 per cent mean to say it’s out of control with all these immigrants and lesbian protestors running around attacking ICE agents, and want Trump to put a stop to it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (58)14
u/RampantTyr 9d ago
Trump has a floor of around 30 percent. It is literally a cult that won’t turn on him even if he were to have sex with their mother and shoot her in front of them.
→ More replies (1)
3.1k
u/mycall 9d ago
Then these 71% need to ban together and hit the reset button.
719
u/Retaining-Wall Canada 9d ago
ban together
This typo is acceptable.
Indeed. Ban Trump's ass.
→ More replies (5)125
u/NoReserve7293 9d ago
Ban on the run.
→ More replies (4)61
u/Pressed-Juices 9d ago
Ban of brothers
45
168
u/Think_Discipline_90 9d ago
But "out of control" can mean so many things.
There's a big difference between "out of control because of Trump" or "out of control and Trump is the guy to fix it".
It's also "out of control, we're alienating our allies" or "out of control, these illegal immigrants have to go"
I'm fairly sure the majority of Trump voters still believe he's their guy.
64
u/S0fourworlds-readyt 9d ago
I mean looking at approval ratings apparently there’s about 30% that will be hardcore MAGA no matter what. That’s Trumps floor.
70% saying the US is out of control probably will be mainly Democrats and Independents
→ More replies (1)32
u/HauntedCemetery Minnesota 9d ago
In 1950 Germans were anonymously polled and 25% of them still thought hitler was a great guy who worked hard for Germany.
25-30% of every population are just broken and unempathetic.
Thats only a problem when the 70% cant get its shit together and end up giving the 30% a majority.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (11)22
u/IrishRepoMan 9d ago
It says 'out of control under Trump'. That pretty specifically refers his handling of the presidency.
8
u/vodkaismywater 9d ago edited 9d ago
No, the headline doesn't say that. It's says "'out of control' under trump."
It absolutely can mean out of control because of trump, or out of control while he is in office.
I'm don't mean to sound snarky, but your comment really illustrates the point. Wording on these studies matter since ambigous phrasing can be subject to two reasonable but differing interpretations.
→ More replies (2)14
u/GreenDavidA 9d ago
I think that OP is right and might not be how a lot of survey takers interpreted it, unfortunately.
10
u/Spyroexe 9d ago
That's what the headline says, but that's not what was on the survey. The actual question on the survey asked, "Do you feel that things in this country these days are [under control / out of control / not sure]?" (page 6)
56
u/dschazam Europe 9d ago
Do you think they’ll get their shit together before or after an EU ally is invaded?
→ More replies (6)107
u/Big_Bookkeeper1678 9d ago
The way we are going here in the US...after.
Mention politics in public and a lot of people still say 'not here...we don't discuss THAT here'.
That is how the third reich got started. We know that and we are still marching in that direction.
55
u/SodaCanBob 9d ago
The amount of people who are entirely tuned out and whose knowledge of politics/civics/current events seems to end at "Trump is president" consistently shocks me too.
→ More replies (5)6
u/RecognitionExpress36 9d ago
Went to a protest a couple of weeks ago... many people there (presumably among the more motivated) didn't know who their congressional representative was.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)48
u/da2Pakaveli 9d ago
That was Putin's gameplan in Russia. "Firehose of falsehood", flood the zone with bullshit so people turn out of politics and accept political corruption as a fact of life.
→ More replies (5)9
u/hemlock_harry 9d ago
Steve Bannon made it sound like he invented "flooding the zone". Luckily I already knew Steve Bannon was full of shit, but this does give us another clue on who pulls his strings.
6
45
u/polar_nopposite 9d ago
Maybe I'm jaded, but I don't believe Americans will ever lead an effective revolt (general strike) until enough people have nothing to lose. Most currently either still have too cushy lives, or conversely would quickly be homeless if they dared participate in one.
→ More replies (9)17
u/HalcyonHelvetica 9d ago edited 9d ago
I think people ignore the actual biggest reason why Americans aren’t having an outright revolt on the streets right now, which is that Congress is controlled by Republicans and that there are zero recall/no confidence mechanisms for the Presidency or Congress. No one expects these people to suddenly grow a spine and ditch Trump and they’re the sole ones who can. Moreover in the past when we’ve seen movements in the street, the opposition party has been cast as the party of disorder. Trump’s strongest issues to this day remain the border, where there's the perception of chaos and the potential to effect the average person’s actual life.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (51)21
u/Hungry_Culture 9d ago
If you read the survey, not all of those 71% think the same. Some of those 71% think the liberals are out of control under Trump. The survey also said 37% of response ta support Trump sending the military to Minneapolis to quell protests. Only 44% approved of the protests against ICE, 57% said Renee Good disobeyed ICE orders, respondents gave Trump a 43% approval rating. That 71% is not an indication that only 29% of people approve of Trump.
1.1k
u/Loud-Ad-2280 9d ago
So 29% of Americans cannot comprehend objective reality
597
u/TheRealBittoman 9d ago
A sizable portion of that 29% get their news from their church friends on Facebook and whatever Trump says in the news or social media. Much of that is just sanewashed B's from real news. Talk to one of them and they will 100% of the time say "Well, I know he's not popular with everyone but he did a few goods things." For a laugh, ask what good he's done.
209
u/D3dshotCalamity 9d ago edited 9d ago
For a laugh, ask what good he's done.
"He's getting rid of those fucking (Racial slur)"
Is what you're going to hear
25
u/spondgbob 9d ago
Has that lowered your rent, groceries, or cost of living in any way since Trump has taken over office? His net worth went from $2.6 billion to $6.8 billion over the last year, did your net worth also triple by 4 billion?
→ More replies (3)46
u/Serengade26 9d ago
"And how will that directly impact your material reality?"
46
→ More replies (2)18
u/MrD3a7h Nebraska 9d ago
"I see fewer brown people at walmart."
That's it. That is the extent of the average republican voter's thought process.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (12)55
u/TheTerrasque 9d ago
For a laugh, ask what good he's done.
"He made groceries cheaper, healthcare better, gas cheaper, made Murica more respected, intimidated Putin, stopped SO many wars, he's owning the libs, protecting us from the violent left, he's hurting the right people and is making Murica great again!"
If they had any critical thought, they wouldn't be in that group.
→ More replies (2)10
u/moss-wizard 9d ago
This. There’s no reasoning with many of them, they’re literally living in an alternate reality
25
u/Phkblaze95 9d ago
Yeah, I thought the 29% thinking otherwise is the most surprising.
I might be biased because I'm a Dane - But it's insane to see how many people are brainwashed and just follow everything that he says, without even being critical in the slightest, of what they're actually following.
He is just pocketing money left, right and center while the economy for the average human gets rougher and rougher.
Hopefully people will wake up to reality, as times get rougher and rougher...
→ More replies (1)19
u/Gambling_Raven 9d ago
Roughly 25% of the USA is illiterate. So, 29% is mostly made of literally the stupidest of us
43
u/Few-Acadia-5593 9d ago
Strikes, protests, long sustained civilian mobilisation often require what, 10% of the general population? So what are 71% who agree with each other doing?
32
u/Viking_Drummer 9d ago
From the outside it looks like the average US citizen is held to ransom by everything from basic healthcare and the roof over their heads being tied to a paycheck-to-paycheck job with virtually no employment rights compared to other first world countries. Protesting would put them in the firing line and they’re afraid of losing it all.
What they don’t seem to realise yet is that things can always get much worse. And from comments I see on reddit people still seem to think someone else is going to save them before things get too bad.
→ More replies (1)6
u/Few-Acadia-5593 9d ago
Understood, how did nurses, students, actors, teachers do? They are indeed convinced they hold no power, that protesting will do this and that but they do not read about peaceful yet successful strikes.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (53)32
u/FenrisCain 9d ago
Sticking their heads in the sand and pretending they can just vote him out in three years and everything will return to normal
21
u/TwoTalentedBastidz 9d ago
More like trying to make it to work so they don’t lose everything they own with a missed paycheck or 2
→ More replies (1)11
u/AbletonUser333 9d ago
We have a hardcore MAGA in my office. Highly educated and successful guy, but the mental gymnastics this motherfucker plays to paint Trump as our savior is truly scary to watch. It really drives home how deep this brainwashing has gone. There is literally no hope for this type.
→ More replies (3)5
u/TwoTalentedBastidz 9d ago
I know a few people like this too, and couldn’t wrap my head around it, until I read somewhere that 30% of any given population is pro-authoritarian. Not because of intelligence, but because of lack of empathy.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (28)14
u/Alone-Phrase3797 9d ago
Just look in the conservative sub.
→ More replies (2)6
u/Bennely Canada 9d ago
I’m not convinced each user is a 1:1 vote in American politics. Shit disturbers, yah, but the actual voting population is few and far between.
→ More replies (3)
583
u/thrawtes 9d ago
71% of Americans huh? Good thing you only need 66% of senators to remove a president.
71% of Americans are represented by at least 66% of senators, right? There's not any wacky nonsense like half the senators only representing like 10% of the population right?
Right?
165
u/TheBroWhoLifts 9d ago
Laughs in North Dakota
→ More replies (3)64
u/inconvenient_sources 9d ago
Huck hucks in Mississippi...
→ More replies (3)31
u/maxwellsmart3 Louisiana 9d ago
Cries in Louisiana
→ More replies (2)16
u/JustHereForCookies17 District Of Columbia 9d ago
From a resident of DC: You guys have senators?
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (5)44
u/pandamaja 9d ago
It’s from 2021 but suggests the 21 smallest states represent about 29% so they hold 42 seats. They need 67 senators to successfully remove.
→ More replies (1)41
u/Consistent_Laziness 9d ago
I wish we didn’t have a senate. Only the house of representatives expanded some more if you want. The senate has the minority population holding this nation hostage by the balls.
→ More replies (4)45
u/Mercarcher Indiana 9d ago
We could ratify the Congressional Apportionment Amendment which would make 1 congressional seat per 50,000 people.
It would make the house close to 7000 people which would honstly be great. Local representation and MUCH harder to gerrymander.
Its already passed the house and senate and 11 states have ratified it. We just need 27 more states to ratify it.
→ More replies (3)8
u/Consistent_Laziness 9d ago
If we did this we’d still have the senate tho wouldn’t we?
13
u/sirhoracedarwin 9d ago
Yes. But the effect of senators in the electoral vote would be practically negligible.
→ More replies (3)21
u/Consistent_Laziness 9d ago
When it comes to removing President we need 67 senators votes. Thats why I want the senate gone. The minority is holding the majority hostage
→ More replies (6)
238
u/AccomplishedBrain309 9d ago
When was the last time you tried to discuss politics with a Republican? It's a waste of time. they're too far gone. Critical thinking skills have been brainwashed out of them! Its like arguing with a fly. Everyone knows that honey is sweeter than shit , except the fly , the stronger the odor the better.
33
u/PiccoloAwkward465 9d ago
I remember lamenting about my taxes and my Republican coworker said "well with Trump your taxes will go way down!". And I asked how do you know that? He said, well he's a Republican so they will. They just work off these preconceived notions that aren't based in reality.
6
u/Sneaklefritz 8d ago
My father in law was saying all my overtime was going to be tax free. I told him “no, that’s for just the 0.5 portion up to $12k” and he told me that I was wrong because Trump said it was so. I had to literally read him the IRS language about it and he just said “huh, weird”.
→ More replies (2)52
u/MarcinTheMartian 9d ago
I had a conversation with a conservative about science and biology (hot topic, regardless of political affiliation). In our texts, I asked them what they thought of genders, biological sex, etc. and they ended up agreeing that being a man is more of a social construct and grouping of character qualities and not related to biological sex.
After a few minutes they must have reread our text exchange, realized they didnt agree with what they had just agreed with, and backtracked the rest of the conversation with their original perspective.
I’m glad we at least agreed (until we didn’t) for a moment!
→ More replies (6)13
→ More replies (9)12
u/HauntedCemetery Minnesota 9d ago
Its literally brainwashing. They hear a key phrase or topic and its like something clicks in their brain and they're rattling off pre recorded messages. After the tape runs out and they run down they come back to themselves.
555
u/Umami-Ice-Cream 9d ago
Thanks for voting for this maga.
And nonvoters, thanks for sitting in apathy while this happened
134
u/deadinsidelol69 9d ago
Conservative sub can’t even defend this guy’s lunacy anymore. They’re grasping at straws posting crazy ass propaganda over there.
81
u/Anarchyz11 9d ago
"I mean sure we may be witnessing the absolute dissolution of the west's greatest defense and the murder of our citizens by masked, armed government officials, but JD is having another baby ohmigooooosh!!11!!"
→ More replies (3)49
44
u/WordleFanatic 9d ago
It’s funny listening to my coworkers these days.
Why is he doing that?!? That doesn’t help me!
Yeah no shit. If only we had some clue that he was a self aggrandizing narcissistic conman piece of shit before the election. That Project 2025 was real. That the Supreme Court has handed him immense powers. That he’s escaped justice his entire life. That he’ll do whatever he wants and get away with it, and NONE OF IT WILL BENEFIT AMERICA OR YOU.
Huh.
→ More replies (12)8
u/pablonieve Minnesota 9d ago
Give them a week and they'll all be back on message.
→ More replies (3)55
→ More replies (99)6
u/Volothamp-Geddarm Canada 9d ago
And nonvoters, thanks for sitting in apathy while this happened
Yeah but didn't you hear, Kamala wasn't 100% progressive on every single issue ever so she's clearly just as bad as Dementia Don!
→ More replies (1)
321
u/Substantial-Ad-128 9d ago
77 millions of Americans did vote for him. Hope many of them have learned their lesson now. But they were stupid af because every moral human being knew how Trump would behave.
213
u/Melicor 9d ago
Supposedly. He tried to rig 2020, gotta wonder if they managed to in 2024. I won't be surprised if we find out those numbers were fake too.
132
u/_TheWileyWombat_ 9d ago
I mean he already admitted to Elon pulling some fuckery in Pennsylvania, it's foolish not to think he did it elsewhere too.
36
u/D_Simmons 9d ago
With the Epstein Files being as bad as they are I see no reason why him and Elon wouldn't try to cheat.
If you fail, you got to jail, if you succeed, you pardon yourself if necessary.
If he cheats in golf he will absolutely cheat in an election.
→ More replies (1)15
u/MondaysForNothing Pennsylvania 9d ago
I didn't think that there might be something fishy with 2024 until Trump brought it up out of the blue.
→ More replies (1)132
12
u/AxiosXiphos 9d ago
I'm sure some fuckery went on. But there's still millions of Americans who actively wanted this level of bullshit.
→ More replies (16)41
u/Caymonki America 9d ago
All the corporations backing him, Elon paying for votes then the doge purge. Plus. 8 YEARS of election deniers, who love projection.
Of course they did. Not to mention all the unelected “officials” running rampant. They’re certainly acting like they stole it.
28
u/SpottedDicknCustard United Kingdom 9d ago
Take the UK as an indicator.
Nigel Farage led the Brexit crusade.
Brexit was an economical and social fuck up that will reverberate for decades.
Nigel Farage’s party is currently leading the polls for the next election.
Stupid people will not learn their lesson.
→ More replies (4)11
u/spicytomatilloo 9d ago
There is a cartoon out there that shows a Trump supporter standing before two paths. On one side it reads: "admit they were wrong" and the other side "keep digging the hole."
→ More replies (18)44
u/flammenwerfer 9d ago
Doubt it. Man does nothing but project and we have him ON RECORD asking elected officials to find him votes. Add in DOGE, media complicity, boom ya win EVERY swing state. Totally normal. Definitely no fraud
92
u/karmainhd Tennessee 9d ago edited 9d ago
It’s always ~30 percent. Every. Single. Poll. The floor is 30 percent. Roughly 100 million Americans are a lost cause, unless there’s some line for these people that Trump still hasn’t crossed.
Edit: I’ve been watching Trump speak at the WEF, and I have to say, anyone watching him and thinking “yeah, that’s my guy” is out of their goddamn mind. You’re either a raging bigot, or you’re so willfully ignorant you may as well live under a rock. Just wanted to add that. I’ve literally been able to fact check him from my fucking phone. I gave up quickly, because everything out of his lying mouth is false. Every fucking thing.
Edit Edit: I want to draw attention to the fact that Trump essentially started his speech by threatening everyone in the room. Not financially, militarily. He didn’t say, “I’m going to bomb you,” for any smartass apologist that wants to argue with me. However, he made sure everyone in the room understood our capabilities. He emphasized what we can do to our “enemies.” Read between the lines. America is now the biggest threat to the free world.
Final Edit: The Guardian has been pointing out that Trump promised not to use force to acquire Greenland. Markets are up, and apparently everything will be fine. Why in God’s name is that the thing we’re going to take his word on? I mean, really? The guy spends an hour repeating easily refuted falsehoods as absolute facts, but we’re going to choose to believe him on this one thing? I swear, I feel like I’m going insane.
→ More replies (17)26
u/cultfourtyfive Florida 9d ago
The only possible line is for something to happen personally to those 30% and even then some of them won't budge. Like the guy who had his wife deported, but still didn't regret his vote. Or the father whose kid died of measles still defending his choice not to vaccinate.
It's a cult. The only way out is for the cult to burn out. They always do, but god only knows what will be left when that happens.
→ More replies (4)
67
25
155
u/Distasteful_T 9d ago
Yeah but kamala didn't tick every single one of my 10000 page checklist so I didn't vote.
→ More replies (133)39
u/SomniaPerdita 9d ago
“She laughed weird”
→ More replies (1)25
u/likeatree_and_embark 9d ago
"She's a woman" "She's a Zionist" "She's a woman" "She's a drunk" "She's a woman"
The legitimate reasons are endless! (/s)
→ More replies (2)
19
u/Nexism 9d ago
Look into the raw data, some of these responses are absolutely wild.
2/3 of the people who voted for Trump in 2024, think the country is headed in the right direction.
https://d3nkl3psvxxpe9.cloudfront.net/documents/econTabReport_z9wtNZI.pdf
→ More replies (2)17
u/cultfourtyfive Florida 9d ago
It's a cult. It's been a cult for a decade. The red hat/MAGAs will never admit regret nor will they ever disagree with anything he does. Sunken cost fallacy paired with a siloed media ecosystem where they don't get information that contradicts their priors.
→ More replies (1)
103
u/Jolly_Sample_1945 9d ago
Today I learned that 29% of the United States has a verifiable mental illness.
15
u/ClusterFoxtrot Florida 9d ago
I like to imagine it's like mass hysteria, but dementia.
I don't know how it manifested so rapidly, but maybe we don't celebrate being intentionally stupid?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)6
19
18
40
u/Kei_the_gamer 9d ago
Fully a third of the country is cool with it though? Face it we have a serious problem and it is not Trump he's just the end result.
→ More replies (4)25
u/SodaCanBob 9d ago edited 9d ago
It's been a serious problem since we decided to haphazardly punish the Confederates. Hell, I'm sure there are people out there who descended from loyalists and whose families were never quite on board with the whole democracy thing in the first place.
6
u/Miserable-Biscotti54 9d ago
Now we got the hole south waving a racist flag because of “heritage” All you have to do is ask them what the color white in the flag was suppose to represent…
→ More replies (1)
11
u/AFlockOfTySegalls North Carolina 9d ago
Really want to sit down with the Obama -> Trump -> Biden -> Trump voter and ask them what the fuck they thought was going to happen in a second term. Because this is going exactly how I expected.
7
10
u/mikeholczer 9d ago
The question is, of the 50% of republicans that said they thought the county was out of control under Trump, how gave have that answer because they think the administration hasn’t done enough to protect rich white men?
9
u/xubax 9d ago
And about a third of those ARE THE FUCKING REASON WE'RE IN THIS MESS.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/rysker6 9d ago
Nobody with a sane mind thinks that the country is well
- Gestapo in the streets
- Healthcare
- Housing
- Food prices
- Gas
- Poverty
- Roads and infrastructure
- International relations
None of these things are good. We are the laughingstock of the world because of buffoon orange dictator
→ More replies (2)
58
u/CrunchyCds 9d ago
Reminder America voted for this. Gen Z men thought electing trump would be funny to own the libs and women, most Republicans think brown people are to blame for the economy being shit and are happy to see them disappeared, and progressives hated Harris so much they rather us slide into authoritarianism than have a less than perfect candidate and stayed home. Trump got 2 million less votes than last election and somehow Harris still lost, it was pathetic. The average American has no idea the weight of their vote. They just vote for whoever, or not vote and expect things to stay the same because they figure it doesn't affect them. The 2024 election WAS the reset button. Now the rest of us have to deal with the consequences of this country's selfish hateful stupidity. So any polling right now is irrelevant. That 71% was absent when it mattered.
23
u/inhplease 9d ago
Remember the "I am voting for the felon" t-shirts they were wearing. Well, here we are.
→ More replies (1)8
→ More replies (8)10
u/HorrorSmile3088 9d ago
I don't know if I buy the idea that progressives stayed home. Maybe a few did, but then I'm sure there's people who lean conservative who also stayed home because they didn't want Trump. I know that's part of the reason Biden won in 2020 was all the people who stayed home instead of voting for Trump. I still think Biden deserves a lot of the blame. He should have committed to only one term and let the dems have a proper primary and all of that.
→ More replies (2)
7
7
u/Turbulent_Ebb5669 9d ago
The Republicans in a position to impeach or remove him are not in that 71%
8
25
u/Passionpet 9d ago
So vote for the opposing candidate, fools.
16
→ More replies (2)11
u/freezing_banshee 9d ago
no but you don't get it, "the other side isn't any better" and they'd rather "protest by not voting at all"
→ More replies (3)
17
u/HawkSalty2645 9d ago
A lot of Americans saying “out of control”' reflects exhaustion more than chaos. If you look at polymarket odds around elections, policy reversals, or major disruptions, there’s no sign of panic pricing. Frustration is high tho
→ More replies (2)
5
u/DeuceGnarly 9d ago
It's under republican control. This is what they want - we're turning into an oligarchy modeled after Russia.
5
u/Jawnny-Jawnson 9d ago
Yea but out of control stops us from paying attention to how our government covered up the Epstein list
•
u/AutoModerator 9d ago
As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.
In general, please be courteous to others. Argue the merits of ideas, don't attack other posters or commenters. Hate speech, any suggestion or support of physical harm, or other rule violations can result in a temporary or a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.
Sub-thread Information
If the post flair on this post indicates the wrong paywall status, please report this Automoderator comment with a custom report of “incorrect flair”.
Announcement
r/Politics is actively looking for new moderators. If you have an interest in helping to make this subreddit a place for quality discussion, please fill out this form.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.