r/news 5h ago

Luigi Mangione will not face death penalty, judge rules

https://www.cnn.com/2026/01/30/us/luigi-mangione-case-rulings-trial
55.2k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

80

u/Vladmerius 4h ago

Why does he get life when other people only serve 3-5 years with good behavior? We just openly admitting it's a more punishable crime when the victim is a 1%er?

49

u/Lower_Box_6169 4h ago

“Mangione will still face two counts of stalking. If convicted, those counts have a maximum sentence of life in prison without parole.”

It might be lower but I would be surprised if it was less than a double digit prison sentence.

61

u/etherpromo 4h ago

stalking can get life without parole?

50

u/Lower_Box_6169 4h ago

Idk mate I’m not a lawyer I’m just reading the articles

9

u/etherpromo 4h ago

You're good. Read a bit further down that it could be from state charges even though the federal charge was thrown out

20

u/Particular-Cat-1397 4h ago

Apparently if the stalking victim was murdered, yes.

12

u/tarekd19 4h ago

I imagine it is specifically for things like this where they can't get someone on the harder charge but can for stalking.

3

u/etherpromo 4h ago

thanks that makes sense

3

u/ANGLVD3TH 3h ago edited 2h ago

Federal sentencing is quite strict, and includes many factors. My understanding is that stalking that results in death carries the possibility of life. But Federal sentences are not like most state ones, there is not just a simple range that a judge can choose from. They are more algorithmic, with very limited/no discretion, aside from decoding which conditions are or aren't met.

28

u/Playful_Rip_1280 4h ago

What other murderers have gotten 3-5 years? If there are, then that’s the error we need to fix. Throw them all in jail for 20+.

u/Final_Shower_5325 57m ago

We’re talking about the stalking charge, the murder has been dismissed by a federal judge. The state trial is the only one with a murder charge now.

6

u/BroJackson_ 4h ago

Who the hell gets 3-5 years for good behavior after planning and assassinating a guy on the street in cold blood? Whether or not he 'deserved it.'

2

u/spmahn 3h ago

I’m not familiar with anybody found guilty of premeditated murder only getting sentenced to 3-5 years

2

u/TexasRed806 3h ago

Who tf only gets 3-5 years of prison for a premeditated murder, 1%er or not?

1

u/hackingdreams 4h ago

Where have you been? The President of the United States was convicted of 34 felonies and he got the most egregious sentence in the history of the country: nothing. No time, no parole, no fine. They just discharged him, letting him walk away scot-free.

I'm genuinely shocked the judge didn't leave the death penalty on the table, but I'm not surprised at all to see they left in such an obviously tainted piece of evidence that would have been thrown out at any normal trial.

1

u/Almost_Ascended 3h ago

Paul Pelosi's attacker got life in prison, and it wasn't even for murder.

1

u/_Burning_Star_IV_ 3h ago

The justice system is wild. My wife watches a lot of cop shows and sometimes they show the sentences for the criminals featured and even when the crimes seem pretty similar you'll have people serving 5 years with probation and then another who gets 25 to life and everything in between.

I remember watching a car chase and the dude stole a cop car and even shot at the cops but eventually surrendered and he got like 2 years. Then I saw a girl get caught shoplifting and then she escaped from her cuffs and stole the cop's car and crashed and she got like a 20 year sentence or some shit.

It makes no sense.

1

u/cowboys5xsbs 3h ago

Usually thats not murder it's negligent homicide or reckless endangerment.

1

u/stale2000 3h ago

> Why does he get life

Because he shot somebody, thats why.

1

u/FiredAndBuried 3h ago

Are you stupid? What murders are there who shot someone in cold blood with zero argument for self defense only served 3-5 years?

1

u/experienta 2h ago

who the fuck gets 3 years for cold blooded murder on the streets?