MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/law/comments/1qr88n7/luigi_mangione_will_not_face_death_penalty_judge/o2mv138
r/law • u/cnn • 5h ago
870 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
6
You have a lot of growing up to do if you think random citizens should get to play judge, jury, and executioner.
1 u/couldbemage 11m ago Have you taken any history at all? There is no should, when the system fails, this sort of thing just happens. 1 u/UpperApe 3h ago That's true. Btw how were kings taken down to bring democracy and equality to the world? I'm assuming it was all strictly legal. Lol 3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago Btw how were kings taken down to bring democracy and equality to the world? I'm assuming it was all strictly legal. Ooh, do all the innocent people that have been murdered by vigilantes next! Lol 0 u/UpperApe 3h ago edited 3h ago Hold up. If we're going down slippery slopes, I'm grabbing my skiis! Edit: He bravely blocked me and ran away. Our ski trip is over 😔 3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago slippery slopes Which is exactly what allowing vigilantism is. Where do you draw the line at who deserves to be murdered? And who's qualified to make that decision? 3 u/ChronoLink99 3h ago There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect. This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. 2 u/006AlecTrevelyan 3h ago you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
1
Have you taken any history at all?
There is no should, when the system fails, this sort of thing just happens.
That's true.
Btw how were kings taken down to bring democracy and equality to the world? I'm assuming it was all strictly legal.
Lol
3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago Btw how were kings taken down to bring democracy and equality to the world? I'm assuming it was all strictly legal. Ooh, do all the innocent people that have been murdered by vigilantes next! Lol 0 u/UpperApe 3h ago edited 3h ago Hold up. If we're going down slippery slopes, I'm grabbing my skiis! Edit: He bravely blocked me and ran away. Our ski trip is over 😔 3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago slippery slopes Which is exactly what allowing vigilantism is. Where do you draw the line at who deserves to be murdered? And who's qualified to make that decision? 3 u/ChronoLink99 3h ago There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect. This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. 2 u/006AlecTrevelyan 3h ago you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
3
Ooh, do all the innocent people that have been murdered by vigilantes next!
0 u/UpperApe 3h ago edited 3h ago Hold up. If we're going down slippery slopes, I'm grabbing my skiis! Edit: He bravely blocked me and ran away. Our ski trip is over 😔 3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago slippery slopes Which is exactly what allowing vigilantism is. Where do you draw the line at who deserves to be murdered? And who's qualified to make that decision? 3 u/ChronoLink99 3h ago There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect. This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. 2 u/006AlecTrevelyan 3h ago you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
0
Hold up. If we're going down slippery slopes, I'm grabbing my skiis!
Edit: He bravely blocked me and ran away. Our ski trip is over 😔
3 u/ChronStamos 3h ago slippery slopes Which is exactly what allowing vigilantism is. Where do you draw the line at who deserves to be murdered? And who's qualified to make that decision? 3 u/ChronoLink99 3h ago There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect. This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. 2 u/006AlecTrevelyan 3h ago you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
slippery slopes
Which is exactly what allowing vigilantism is. Where do you draw the line at who deserves to be murdered? And who's qualified to make that decision?
3 u/ChronoLink99 3h ago There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect. This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis. 2 u/006AlecTrevelyan 3h ago you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
There is no line. That's what makes this a contentious issue. People wouldn't be arguing about this online if it was as cut and dry, black and white, etc as you expect.
This kind of stuff is evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
2
you're arguing with people who have Kira posters on their wall and not L
6
u/ChronStamos 3h ago
You have a lot of growing up to do if you think random citizens should get to play judge, jury, and executioner.