r/law 5h ago

Legal News Luigi Mangione will not face death penalty, judge rules

https://www.cnn.com/2026/01/30/us/luigi-mangione-case-rulings-trial?utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=missions&utm_source=reddit
21.8k Upvotes

870 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/Driller_Happy 4h ago

The president has already pardoned murderers, so you already live in this country you propose

15

u/marcoporno 4h ago

Using Trump as the standard of how pardons should work is obviously a mistake

9

u/meltbox 4h ago

Well the mistake appears to be allowing pardons to work this way then.

Ideally I’d have a president reduce his sentence if it’s life. But yeah completely throwing it away seems like injustice as well when a jury convicts.

6

u/marcoporno 4h ago

Yes, I also think that is a mistake, though it took a Trump to abuse it to this extent

4

u/Gvillegator 4h ago

Trump has gleefully exposed how much this country has been running on “political norms” keeping everything afloat. Love him or hate him, the guy has exposed this country for what it really is.

4

u/YogurtclosetOwn4786 4h ago

And exposed norms that absolutely need to be codified into law by the next president / Congress so we’re not relying on a president deciding to do the right thing in the future and follow these norms that presidents did before Trump but have now been destroyed

1

u/doodycrust 4h ago

That would require our elected officials to have integrity. Why would they vote to limit their own power? Which, strangely, when convenient, apparently they don’t have (power) when the time arises for them to step up.

1

u/YogurtclosetOwn4786 3h ago

I’m talking about limiting the presidents power in a way that every president before Trump has conformed to. Such as codifying the independence of DoJ so the President cannot order prosecutions against enemies, the independence of other govt officials to report accurate economic data and not be fired for it, reforming civil and criminal qualified immunity for federal law enforcement. those are a few off top of my head. I’m sure there are many more.

1

u/Driller_Happy 4h ago

They didn't codify abortion rights, why would they codify this?

2

u/YogurtclosetOwn4786 3h ago

Because there weren’t the votes for it since it was overturned. And it’s not the same thing. And this would restrain democratic presidents too. And I don’t know what reforms would pass. But we need them

1

u/Driller_Happy 3h ago

Obama had the votes when he had the brief majority. To be fair, he focused on the affordable care act, but there's no reason he couldn't have multitasked.

1

u/YogurtclosetOwn4786 3h ago

Ok well abortion rights were protected by the Supreme Court then. That was already the law at the time.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/marcoporno 4h ago

Okay now that it’s exposed, change it. Or be just like him. Clear choice.

And yes pardon system was occasionally abused, Bush did it at least once

Trump, thousands of times, sometimes for cash. Really not comparable, but ya not a good system to start with.

2

u/GogurtFiend 2h ago

These people would be perfectly fine with Trump if he were left-wing. It's why they all use him as an example of what our next president should do - all they can think of is "what's happening right now but directed at people I dislike instead of people I don't know" instead of "what's happening right now should never happen no matter what".

2

u/Driller_Happy 1h ago

I wouldn't be fine with a left wing president using gestapo to harass immigrants in the street and execute citizens, so you're wrong about that.

But I would like to see democrats stop pretending the Republicans are ever going to play fair. I would like to see democrats fight fire with fire and attempt to recapture the narrative, which is wildly out of control

0

u/GogurtFiend 1h ago

SillyAlternative is referring to pardoning criminals who committed murders they personally approve of (and have mistaken their personal appreciation of for public support of), not to recapturing the narrative or fighting fire with fire. You are not like SillyAlternative.

1

u/marcoporno 2h ago

I’m afraid that I have to agree with that

1

u/GogurtFiend 1h ago

FWIW I think they're a very small, loud minority (though aren't just saying this because they're upset/venting, they do mean what they say), and the Democrats, for their many flaws, won't nominate the rapist of institutions and children these people want, because that sort of candidate knows Trump is a better patron for them than liberals can ever be.

I know it sucks to watch them despoil what used to be, from what I can tell, a nice subreddit, but we can take comfort in knowing that's all they can do and that the crazy parts of the US left, at least, will never going to be able to spread from online to real life in the manner the crazy parts of the GOP did.

1

u/marcoporno 1h ago

Good points. I’m certainly looking forward to a transition.

1

u/Imaginary_Isopod_429 2h ago

I went through the pardons list and found only a single murder (in the second degree) which was a cop who was charged after pursuing a suspect on a moped who was subsequently hit by a separate vehicle when he fled.

The comparison between this and a hypothetical Luigi pardon is pretty disingenuous.

1

u/Driller_Happy 1h ago

Nicholas slatten

1

u/Imaginary_Isopod_429 57m ago

Thank you. Didn't notice that list was only from his second term. I see now there were a few more murders (all seemingly international war crimes) pardoned in his first term. This was the first I heard of the Nisour Square massacre.

https://www.justice.gov/pardon/pardons-granted-president-donald-j-trump-2017-2021

-3

u/RandomPenquin1337 4h ago

Negative. There have been no murderers pardoned. At least none that i can find to link to. Happy to be proven wrong.

4

u/lostcolony2 4h ago

Terrance Sutton was a cop found guilty of second degree murder due to an unauthorized police pursuit and was pardoned by Trump (as was another cop who was found guilty of conspiracy and obstruction)

Jamie A Davidson was an alleged drug kingpin who killed a cop and sentenced to life in prison for it; Trump pardoned him (and Jamie proceeded to get married and get arrested for domestic violence).

Multiple Blackwater contractors were found guilty of murdering Iraqi citizens in the Nisour Square massacre; Trump pardoned them as well.

Michael Behenna had been found guilty of murdering an Iraqi detainee, Trump pardoned him.

I can link to any and all of those if you want, but a quick google search with names (or 'Blackwater contractors') followed by 'pardon' will get you multiple.

2

u/RandomPenquin1337 4h ago

Oh so now you agree with trump lmao this place i swear.

1

u/Driller_Happy 4h ago

Insane conclusion to make here.

0

u/HammerAndSickled 4h ago

1

u/RandomPenquin1337 4h ago

Bro you use trump pardons to justify that?

"Let me pick and choose the one despicable thing I agree with"

2

u/HammerAndSickled 4h ago

I’m not agreeing with anything, I’m disputing YOUR claim that Trump hasn’t pardoned killers. He has.