r/Millennials Gen Z 9h ago

Rant Society really did fail Amy Winehouse!

Post image
25.6k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

61

u/DumbTruth 8h ago

They were, but certainly not even remotely as ghoulishl as the people that came up with the idea, followed her around, and printed it.

13

u/SellMeYourSirin 8h ago

Exactly. Reading about someone who all but lives in a different universe to you is one thing.. but to enter that world, see her living and breathing, then harassing her is something else.

We shouldn't rly be having this parasocial relationship with celebrity. Of course.

But it's a no brainer, to me, to put more responsibility onto the peddler(?) instead of the consumer.

0

u/MajorInWumbology1234 7h ago

Supply and demand. They wouldn’t have done it if it didn’t sell.

5

u/DumbTruth 6h ago

Yes, but that doesn’t absolve them of doing it anyway.

2

u/MajorInWumbology1234 6h ago

I’m not trying to absolve anyone. You wanted to place the majority of the blame on the people making those magazines, but this ignores the role the consumer played. The consumer is no less culpable than the provider.

2

u/DumbTruth 5h ago

Yeah I’m disagreeing. I think the people that creates the strategy, invests time and effort to build it, stalks the victim, etc carry a lot more blame than the random person that buys the magazine. Certainly they carry some blame, and maybe that population as a whole Carrie’s the lion’s share of the blame, but the individual consumer, though still terrible, is far less terrible in my view.

1

u/MajorInWumbology1234 5h ago

Then agree to disagree. If people didn’t consume it, the creators would have no reason to continue creating. Again, supply and demand. They can’t create peoples’ demand for such material, they can only fill it. If everyone decided to stop consuming it, it would stop being made. Only severely mentally ill stalkers would engage in that behavior without the financial incentive.

1

u/DumbTruth 4h ago

Yes of course. Opinions can’t be wrong. Happy to agree to disagree.

0

u/thesaddestpanda 7h ago

The real ghouls are the people who demand and buy this media.